Not sure which to keep, which to expunge - E-Hentai Forums

Logged in as: k999k99 ( Log Out )

My Controls · View New Posts · My Assistant · 0 New Messages

E-Hentai Forums > E-Hentai Website Forums > The Vigilante

Not sure which to keep, which to expunge, For specific cases e.g. quality is difficult to judge

Apr 19 2011, 11:52 Post #1
Red of EHCOVE Viceroy of Oook & EHCOVE cofounder Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 9,478 Joined: 28-April 07 Level 354 (Godslayer) +K	- Mod Notice - If you are not sure which of the two (or more) similar galleries should be expunged, or whether the gallery qualifies for a "defaced" expunge, post your inquiries in this thread. Any expunge/de-expunge requests, or questions on certain expunge/appeal petitions, please visit this thread: --> Expunging, Appealing and Reverting Assistance ------------------------------------------------------------ Often enough I run into situations when I am not sure which gallery to keep. Posting them in the reup vigi thead sometimes helps, but often my posts seem to be ignored, as they fall behind the current vigi "expunge this" steamroller posts. And I've seen this happen to others. This is the place to post the "not sure" cases, so they can get more visibility. Here's my most recent one: http://ehentaihip.com/g/6411/88fe54ba3c/ (org) http://ehentaihip.com/g/17873/8ae33a5bbc/ (reup) Org has bigger filesize but lower res then reup. Which to keep, or both? This post has been edited by PrincessKaguya: Apr 28 2022, 19:23 -------------------- Tag check Backlogs: expunge rename K+ Created tags you can blame me for: clamp (def, use), clone (def, use), closed eyes (def, use), dismantling (def, use), facial hair (def, use), fishnets (def, use), hair buns (def, use), headless (def, use), hood (def, use), horns (def, use), kemonomimi (def, use), missing cover (def, use), sarashi (def, use), sketch lines (def, use), soushuuhen (def, use), tail (def, use) Tags significantly changed: filming (def, use), large tattoo (def, use), exhibitionism Interesting tag proposals/revisions under discussion (please consider commenting): anon, below knee boots, calendar, clueless (aka naive), couple (two people having sex), eye-covering bang, hat, helmet, husband and wife (aka married couple, spouse), phone/camera scan, under knee high boots / below knee boots, watching Tags I am thinking about proposing (be scared / PM me with comments/examples): butt plug, covered in cum, halo, high heels, metal bikini, mentally retarded, miniskirt, ribbon headband, samurai, self-sucking, socks, flora/vegetable insertion (please post examples here), veil Play some games and rip them for the galleries My scan commissions Can you read Japanese? Do you want lots of GP/creds/hath? Visit our bounty subforum! Extra rewards if you translate posted EHCOVE bounties or my proposed projects here! (Also looking for editors and proofreaders). Celebrate EHCOVE's 5th Anniversary and check out our first exclusive Artist/Game CG set release, the OPTC Nude Project: A Man's Dream

125 Pages

< 1 2 3 4 > »

Reply to this topic

Start new topic

Replies(20 - 39)

May 22 2011, 09:24 Post #21
Ichizon 一存 Group: Members Posts: 734 Joined: 9-December 09 Level 305 (Godslayer) +K	QUOTE(Maximum_Joe @ May 21 2011, 22:07) New; http://ehentaihip.com/g/368881/e0fc7bdd5b/ Old: http://ehentaihip.com/g/61467/d7b5065060/ Image for image, the new one looks like a cropped and more blurry (look at the lines in image 007 (new) vs. 005 (old)) version of the exact same scan. The blur might be due to E-H downsizing different sized images, though on that basis, I'd call the new one a dupe. The new one does have three extra non-story scans, 003, 004 and 198, but I wouldn't replace what seems like a slightly better scan due to that. Simply uploading those three pages with the old scan seems like a bad idea also, as it would be best to find the originals. Conclusion: I'd vote out the new one, but uncertain.

May 22 2011, 13:33 Post #22
Red of EHCOVE Viceroy of Oook & EHCOVE cofounder Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 9,478 Joined: 28-April 07 Level 354 (Godslayer) +K	Low quality but more complete = both stay -------------------- Tag check Backlogs: expunge rename K+ Created tags you can blame me for: clamp (def, use), clone (def, use), closed eyes (def, use), dismantling (def, use), facial hair (def, use), fishnets (def, use), hair buns (def, use), headless (def, use), hood (def, use), horns (def, use), kemonomimi (def, use), missing cover (def, use), sarashi (def, use), sketch lines (def, use), soushuuhen (def, use), tail (def, use) Tags significantly changed: filming (def, use), large tattoo (def, use), exhibitionism Interesting tag proposals/revisions under discussion (please consider commenting): anon, below knee boots, calendar, clueless (aka naive), couple (two people having sex), eye-covering bang, hat, helmet, husband and wife (aka married couple, spouse), phone/camera scan, under knee high boots / below knee boots, watching Tags I am thinking about proposing (be scared / PM me with comments/examples): butt plug, covered in cum, halo, high heels, metal bikini, mentally retarded, miniskirt, ribbon headband, samurai, self-sucking, socks, flora/vegetable insertion (please post examples here), veil Play some games and rip them for the galleries My scan commissions Can you read Japanese? Do you want lots of GP/creds/hath? Visit our bounty subforum! Extra rewards if you translate posted EHCOVE bounties or my proposed projects here! (Also looking for editors and proofreaders). Celebrate EHCOVE's 5th Anniversary and check out our first exclusive Artist/Game CG set release, the OPTC Nude Project: A Man's Dream

May 24 2011, 02:36 Post #23
chivoef Tragic hero Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 4,061 Joined: 12-January 10 Level 500 (Hero) +K	http://ehentaihip.com/g/19361/7d04b9e73a/ (org) vs. http://ehentaihip.com/g/369758/329d74f07c/ (re-up) Page 219-220 are duplicates in the original, re-up has everything correct as far as I can tell. Ground enough for replacement or not? It's pretty minimal, not even a story page but it is more complete technically. This post has been edited by chivoef: May 24 2011, 02:50

May 24 2011, 05:22 Post #24
Red of EHCOVE Viceroy of Oook & EHCOVE cofounder Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 9,478 Joined: 28-April 07 Level 354 (Godslayer) +K	mostly sure, but... reup has bigger filesize and res, but looks perhaps less sharp? Second opinion appreciated http://ehentaihip.com/g/91128/4b208437d1/ (org) http://ehentaihip.com/g/369794/9baa7baecf/ (reup) -------------------- Tag check Backlogs: expunge rename K+ Created tags you can blame me for: clamp (def, use), clone (def, use), closed eyes (def, use), dismantling (def, use), facial hair (def, use), fishnets (def, use), hair buns (def, use), headless (def, use), hood (def, use), horns (def, use), kemonomimi (def, use), missing cover (def, use), sarashi (def, use), sketch lines (def, use), soushuuhen (def, use), tail (def, use) Tags significantly changed: filming (def, use), large tattoo (def, use), exhibitionism Interesting tag proposals/revisions under discussion (please consider commenting): anon, below knee boots, calendar, clueless (aka naive), couple (two people having sex), eye-covering bang, hat, helmet, husband and wife (aka married couple, spouse), phone/camera scan, under knee high boots / below knee boots, watching Tags I am thinking about proposing (be scared / PM me with comments/examples): butt plug, covered in cum, halo, high heels, metal bikini, mentally retarded, miniskirt, ribbon headband, samurai, self-sucking, socks, flora/vegetable insertion (please post examples here), veil Play some games and rip them for the galleries My scan commissions Can you read Japanese? Do you want lots of GP/creds/hath? Visit our bounty subforum! Extra rewards if you translate posted EHCOVE bounties or my proposed projects here! (Also looking for editors and proofreaders). Celebrate EHCOVE's 5th Anniversary and check out our first exclusive Artist/Game CG set release, the OPTC Nude Project: A Man's Dream

May 26 2011, 22:10 Post #25
pop9 Forever Alone Group: Members Posts: 26,039 Joined: 6-May 09 Level 500 (Dovahkiin) +K	QUOTE(SingleMalt @ May 26 2011, 15:31) For your consideration: [Elf] AV King Older but smaller gallery [#1] http://ehentaihip.com/g/87807/5c0363f080/ Younger, complete gallery [#2] http://ehentaihip.com/g/220066/94e0bde222/ Images in #1 are slightly bigger (around 10kb each), but #2's have better colour dithering (example: [#1] vs [#2]). I can't say that #1's images are significantly better when it comes to other compression artefacts either. What say you, vigilante veterans? -------------------- +++

May 30 2011, 11:38 Post #26
Ichizon 一存 Group: Members Posts: 734 Joined: 9-December 09 Level 305 (Godslayer) +K	Original upload by Painload http://ehentaihip.com/g/288457/5a407c554d/ Dupe upload by Spectre http://ehentaihip.com/g/290433/773cd15f07/ Filesizes are different, which is why I'm unsure. They both look pretty much the same, and don't seem to be resized by the site. From what I gather, both are digital. [www.dlsite.com] DLsite states 40 pages pdf. The question is which is better to keep? DLsite says the PDF is zipped to 10.36 MB, so Spectre's "dupe" might be a lossless PDF rip, where the Painload's might be a badly oversized rip. Opinions? [www.toranoana.jp] This looks like the physical version at 44 pages. Also notice the third preview's censor bar, which is not present in any of the above doujins (page 35). Both of these use digital mosaic instead.

May 30 2011, 16:34 Post #27
Dlaglacz Retired Galleries Maintenance Drone Group: Catgirl Camarilla Posts: 7,899 Joined: 6-March 08 Level 156 (Lord) +K	QUOTE(Ichizon @ May 30 2011, 05:38) [www.dlsite.com] DLsite states 40 pages pdf. The question is which is better to keep? DLsite says the PDF is zipped to 10.36 MB, so Spectre's "dupe" might be a lossless PDF rip, where the Painload's might be a badly oversized rip. Opinions? I see the same compression artifacts around kanji in both galleries, and at this file size they shouldn't be happening, so at least Painload's one is oversized. I dont see any differences between galleries. I'm not sure what the rules are lately, common sense tells me it would take less space and download bandwidth to keep Spectre's gallery, but I suppose the rules would say to kill the dupe.

May 31 2011, 11:07 Post #28
Red of EHCOVE Viceroy of Oook & EHCOVE cofounder Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 9,478 Joined: 28-April 07 Level 354 (Godslayer) +K	seems like same res and quality, but reup has higher filesize http://ehentaihip.com/g/15460/261bd45e21/ (org) http://ehentaihip.com/g/163502/20a34d65ae/ (reup) -------------------- Tag check Backlogs: expunge rename K+ Created tags you can blame me for: clamp (def, use), clone (def, use), closed eyes (def, use), dismantling (def, use), facial hair (def, use), fishnets (def, use), hair buns (def, use), headless (def, use), hood (def, use), horns (def, use), kemonomimi (def, use), missing cover (def, use), sarashi (def, use), sketch lines (def, use), soushuuhen (def, use), tail (def, use) Tags significantly changed: filming (def, use), large tattoo (def, use), exhibitionism Interesting tag proposals/revisions under discussion (please consider commenting): anon, below knee boots, calendar, clueless (aka naive), couple (two people having sex), eye-covering bang, hat, helmet, husband and wife (aka married couple, spouse), phone/camera scan, under knee high boots / below knee boots, watching Tags I am thinking about proposing (be scared / PM me with comments/examples): butt plug, covered in cum, halo, high heels, metal bikini, mentally retarded, miniskirt, ribbon headband, samurai, self-sucking, socks, flora/vegetable insertion (please post examples here), veil Play some games and rip them for the galleries My scan commissions Can you read Japanese? Do you want lots of GP/creds/hath? Visit our bounty subforum! Extra rewards if you translate posted EHCOVE bounties or my proposed projects here! (Also looking for editors and proofreaders). Celebrate EHCOVE's 5th Anniversary and check out our first exclusive Artist/Game CG set release, the OPTC Nude Project: A Man's Dream

May 31 2011, 15:15 Post #29
Ichizon 一存 Group: Members Posts: 734 Joined: 9-December 09 Level 305 (Godslayer) +K	While it is very hard to discern, the older/smaller gallery has a light case of JPG artifacts, evident from the cover. Look at the palm of her hand, for instance. While it is possible that the larger one has been cleaned as they are evidently from the same scan, I'd vouch for keeping the larger one.

Jun 2 2011, 05:02 Post #30
Spectre The Bell Tolls for All. Group: Global Mods Posts: 8,349 Joined: 8-February 06 Level 269 (Godslayer) +K	QUOTE(Dlaglacz @ May 30 2011, 04:34) I see the same compression artifacts around kanji in both galleries, and at this file size they shouldn't be happening, so at least Painload's one is oversized. I dont see any differences between galleries. I'm not sure what the rules are lately, common sense tells me it would take less space and download bandwidth to keep Spectre's gallery, but I suppose the rules would say to kill the dupe. My copy was off of Share and came with the PDF and those images, the filename suggesting that it contained a scanned version and the DL version... shrug. I'd personally go with as close to "as released" as possible, but even that is technically in the air. shrug -------------------- QUOTE Spectre: you're crying on the inside aren't you? BunBun: slightly BunBun: it's kind of like BunBun: a tear ran down my face BunBun: and you licked it off and laughed Spectre: XDD When you do things right, people won’t be sure you’ve done anything at all. ↓ Click Me! ↓ {/assist} {Can I have it?} {Please Check it.} {Thank you.} My Uploads

Jun 4 2011, 08:12 Post #31
Red of EHCOVE Viceroy of Oook & EHCOVE cofounder Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 9,478 Joined: 28-April 07 Level 354 (Godslayer) +K	http://ehentaihip.com/g/3166/54f3de7b6b/ (org) http://ehentaihip.com/g/36208/6b73ce0911/ (Snowflake reup, slightly higher filesize, lower res) Keep the org? Or is it some resize? -------------------- Tag check Backlogs: expunge rename K+ Created tags you can blame me for: clamp (def, use), clone (def, use), closed eyes (def, use), dismantling (def, use), facial hair (def, use), fishnets (def, use), hair buns (def, use), headless (def, use), hood (def, use), horns (def, use), kemonomimi (def, use), missing cover (def, use), sarashi (def, use), sketch lines (def, use), soushuuhen (def, use), tail (def, use) Tags significantly changed: filming (def, use), large tattoo (def, use), exhibitionism Interesting tag proposals/revisions under discussion (please consider commenting): anon, below knee boots, calendar, clueless (aka naive), couple (two people having sex), eye-covering bang, hat, helmet, husband and wife (aka married couple, spouse), phone/camera scan, under knee high boots / below knee boots, watching Tags I am thinking about proposing (be scared / PM me with comments/examples): butt plug, covered in cum, halo, high heels, metal bikini, mentally retarded, miniskirt, ribbon headband, samurai, self-sucking, socks, flora/vegetable insertion (please post examples here), veil Play some games and rip them for the galleries My scan commissions Can you read Japanese? Do you want lots of GP/creds/hath? Visit our bounty subforum! Extra rewards if you translate posted EHCOVE bounties or my proposed projects here! (Also looking for editors and proofreaders). Celebrate EHCOVE's 5th Anniversary and check out our first exclusive Artist/Game CG set release, the OPTC Nude Project: A Man's Dream

Jun 10 2011, 22:49 Post #32
Maximum_Joe Legendary Poster Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 24,074 Joined: 17-April 11 Level 500 (Dovahkiin) +K	http://ehentaihip.com/g/44218/5adbfd2530/ (watermarked, smaller filesize) http://ehentaihip.com/g/102163/a16ed86286/ (larger filesize) This post has been edited by Maximum_Joe: Jun 11 2011, 02:28 -------------------- Try to fill your life with good things.

Jun 11 2011, 03:46 Post #33
Maximum_Joe Legendary Poster Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 24,074 Joined: 17-April 11 Level 500 (Dovahkiin) +K	http://ehentaihip.com/g/29244/8529835b8d/ http://ehentaihip.com/g/376003/30fd32fd8a/ Pretty sure the newer one just has the preview pics added, but I'm not 100%. http://ehentaihip.com/g/376095/9dc22df6d5/ (missing cover) http://ehentaihip.com/g/26323/7a444aadec/ (missing omake) This post has been edited by Maximum_Joe: Jun 11 2011, 08:07 -------------------- Try to fill your life with good things.

Jun 12 2011, 11:15 Post #34
G Just G Casual Poster Group: Members Posts: 411 Joined: 28-October 08 Level 167 (Lord) +K	http://ehentaihip.com/g/376446/a6a19a4e2f/ and http://ehentaihip.com/g/315873/1843302941/ -------------------- Now 27% less broken!

Jun 17 2011, 17:11 Post #35
pop9 Forever Alone Group: Members Posts: 26,039 Joined: 6-May 09 Level 500 (Dovahkiin) +K	(C53) [Momo No Tsubomi (Hoshino Fuuta)] Lolikko LOVE 8 http://ehentaihip.com/g/374678/2be0232921/ 82 @ 25.40 MB 2011-06-06 16:13 ravage http://ehentaihip.com/s/5beb3b54fe/374678-1 http://ehentaihip.com/s/daf28886d0/374678-4 http://ehentaihip.com/g/374328/ffbbeb2979/ 82 @ 26.80 MB 2011-06-05 16:28 ravage http://ehentaihip.com/s/172c75c286/374328-1 http://ehentaihip.com/s/20982796b0/374328-4 QUOTE(G Just G @ Jun 12 2011, 05:15) http://ehentaihip.com/g/376446/a6a19a4e2f/ and http://ehentaihip.com/g/315873/1843302941/ Both Stay Yours - PDF Digital rip begbeg's - paper scan This post has been edited by pop9: Jun 17 2011, 18:18 -------------------- +++

Jun 19 2011, 20:01 Post #36
r3dd0ssal Elite Poster Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 6,823 Joined: 23-February 07 Level 370 (Godslayer) +K	Not sure if the new one is just an upscale or not. original: http://ehentaihip.com/g/370256/47691b5136/ new: http://ehentaihip.com/g/379199/2a944b8f71/

Jun 19 2011, 22:29 Post #37
pop9 Forever Alone Group: Members Posts: 26,039 Joined: 6-May 09 Level 500 (Dovahkiin) +K	QUOTE(DemonEyesBob @ Jun 19 2011, 14:01) Not sure if the new one is just an upscale or not. original: http://ehentaihip.com/g/370256/47691b5136/ new: http://ehentaihip.com/g/379199/2a944b8f71/ not upscale.. http://ehentaihip.com/g/379199/2a944b8f71/ scanned by moguu (First Limited Edition w/ cd label scan & the link to mp3 rip) -------------------- +++

Jun 23 2011, 09:38 Post #38
Red of EHCOVE Viceroy of Oook & EHCOVE cofounder Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 9,478 Joined: 28-April 07 Level 354 (Godslayer) +K	http://ehentaihip.com/g/48778/58d53508a5/ (org) http://ehentaihip.com/g/141608/87828fb4d7/ (reup - same res, lower filesize) Is the reup lower quality and thus a dupe? Likely but... -------------------- Tag check Backlogs: expunge rename K+ Created tags you can blame me for: clamp (def, use), clone (def, use), closed eyes (def, use), dismantling (def, use), facial hair (def, use), fishnets (def, use), hair buns (def, use), headless (def, use), hood (def, use), horns (def, use), kemonomimi (def, use), missing cover (def, use), sarashi (def, use), sketch lines (def, use), soushuuhen (def, use), tail (def, use) Tags significantly changed: filming (def, use), large tattoo (def, use), exhibitionism Interesting tag proposals/revisions under discussion (please consider commenting): anon, below knee boots, calendar, clueless (aka naive), couple (two people having sex), eye-covering bang, hat, helmet, husband and wife (aka married couple, spouse), phone/camera scan, under knee high boots / below knee boots, watching Tags I am thinking about proposing (be scared / PM me with comments/examples): butt plug, covered in cum, halo, high heels, metal bikini, mentally retarded, miniskirt, ribbon headband, samurai, self-sucking, socks, flora/vegetable insertion (please post examples here), veil Play some games and rip them for the galleries My scan commissions Can you read Japanese? Do you want lots of GP/creds/hath? Visit our bounty subforum! Extra rewards if you translate posted EHCOVE bounties or my proposed projects here! (Also looking for editors and proofreaders). Celebrate EHCOVE's 5th Anniversary and check out our first exclusive Artist/Game CG set release, the OPTC Nude Project: A Man's Dream

Jun 24 2011, 12:07 Post #39
Red of EHCOVE Viceroy of Oook & EHCOVE cofounder Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 9,478 Joined: 28-April 07 Level 354 (Godslayer) +K	http://ehentaihip.com/g/45834/1900bec63b/ (org) http://ehentaihip.com/g/179994/b9873769f4/ (reup) the only difference in reup seems to be ~10% higher filesize... dupe, or is there a quality improvement? -------------------- Tag check Backlogs: expunge rename K+ Created tags you can blame me for: clamp (def, use), clone (def, use), closed eyes (def, use), dismantling (def, use), facial hair (def, use), fishnets (def, use), hair buns (def, use), headless (def, use), hood (def, use), horns (def, use), kemonomimi (def, use), missing cover (def, use), sarashi (def, use), sketch lines (def, use), soushuuhen (def, use), tail (def, use) Tags significantly changed: filming (def, use), large tattoo (def, use), exhibitionism Interesting tag proposals/revisions under discussion (please consider commenting): anon, below knee boots, calendar, clueless (aka naive), couple (two people having sex), eye-covering bang, hat, helmet, husband and wife (aka married couple, spouse), phone/camera scan, under knee high boots / below knee boots, watching Tags I am thinking about proposing (be scared / PM me with comments/examples): butt plug, covered in cum, halo, high heels, metal bikini, mentally retarded, miniskirt, ribbon headband, samurai, self-sucking, socks, flora/vegetable insertion (please post examples here), veil Play some games and rip them for the galleries My scan commissions Can you read Japanese? Do you want lots of GP/creds/hath? Visit our bounty subforum! Extra rewards if you translate posted EHCOVE bounties or my proposed projects here! (Also looking for editors and proofreaders). Celebrate EHCOVE's 5th Anniversary and check out our first exclusive Artist/Game CG set release, the OPTC Nude Project: A Man's Dream

Jun 24 2011, 12:12 Post #40
r3dd0ssal Elite Poster Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 6,823 Joined: 23-February 07 Level 370 (Godslayer) +K	QUOTE(Red_Piotrus @ Jun 24 2011, 00:07) http://ehentaihip.com/g/45834/1900bec63b/ (org) http://ehentaihip.com/g/179994/b9873769f4/ (reup) the only difference in reup seems to be ~10% higher filesize... dupe, or is there a quality improvement? The re-up is better. If you look closely the lines are cleaner - there are less artifacts. Awing wins the day ^^ This post has been edited by DemonEyesBob: Jun 24 2011, 12:15

« Next Oldest · The Vigilante · Next Newest »

125 Pages

< 1 2 3 4 > »

Fast Reply

Reply to this topic

Start new topic

1 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)

1 Members: k999k99

Display Mode: Switch to: Standard · Linear+ · Switch to: Outline

Track this topic · Email this topic · Print this topic · Subscribe to this forum

Invisible Power Broads © IPS, Inc.

Licensed to: EHentaiHip.com

Lo-Fi Version

Time is now: 27th September 2022 - 17:50